25 August 2002
Source of maps and photos: Mapquest.com
(color) and TerraServer
USGS 31 Jan 1995 (monochrome).
http://web.dandp.com/n45/pp_2000/Team_CNO.pdf
Remediation of Perchlorate Contamination in Soil and Groundwater
Department of the Navy, Southern Division
Environmental Restoration Environmental Restoration Team
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The Naval Weapons Industrial Reserve Plant (NWIRP) McGregor project team
has achieved remarkable results while simultaneously coordinating a multitask
perchlorate groundwater investigation for 9,600 acres onsite and 22,000 acres
offsite. At the same time the team has transferred ownership of approximately
3,500 acres of the facility to the City of McGregor to satisfy U.S. Rep.
Chet Edwards 1996 special legislation. Due to the high visibility of
this work at the national and congressional level, members of the team worked
with senior military officials (including Elsie Munsell, Admirals Baucom,
Brewer, and Grunuzzo); U.S. Rep. Chet Edwards and Senators Phil Gramm and
Kay Bailey Hutchison while facilitating relationships between two System
Commands and multiple Southern Division Naval Facilities Engineering Command
(SOUTHDIV) departments.
Despite the tremendous challenges faced by the team, dramatic cost savings
were achieved during 2000. This was made possible by the implementation of
in situ bioremediation of contaminants at the facility. The use of in situ
technologies, successfully demonstrated during simultaneous bench-scale studies,
eliminated the need for currently existing ex situ units, alternate ex situ
treatment technologies, and their associated permitting costs. This decision
alone saved SOUTHDIV more than $6.5 million of ER,N funding in FY-00, an
amount roughly equivalent to 17% of the entire SOUTHDIV ER,N budget.
The McGregor project team was recognized and won the Grand Award from the
Consulting Engineers of Tennessee in association with the American Consulting
Engineers Council (ACEC) for the innovative and low-cost remediation of
perchlorate contaminated groundwater through an in situ system. Further,
the Navys project manager, Mr. Mark Craig, has received additional
commendations for his work on the project. In recognition of his leadership,
which has exceeded the normal expertise and requirements of his position,
he received letters of commendation from the City of McGregor and the Naval
Air Systems Command. In addition, he received Special Act awards, was selected
as the Southern Division Environmental Restoration Employee of the Year for
1999, Southern Division Associate of the Year for 2000, and the Federal Employee
of the Year for the Greater Charleston Area for 2000.
2.0 ENVIRONMENTAL BACKGROUND
NWIRP McGregor is a government-owned, contractor-operated facility in McGregor,
Texas, approximately 20 miles southwest of Waco. The U.S. Army Ordnance Corps
originally established it in 1942 as the Bluebonnet Ordnance Plant. Over
the facilitys 50-year history, owners included the U.S. Army, U.S.
Air Force, and its current owner, the U.S. Navys Naval Air Systems
Command (NAVAIR). Industrial activities at the site included weapons and
solid-fuel rocket propulsion systems manufacturing.
During its prime, NWIRP McGregor utilized 1,400 workers and was the largest
employer in the area. Revenues from the facility supported the economies
of many local communities, such as the cities of McGregor, Waco, Temple,
Killeen, and Belton. At the time of the facilitys closure in 1995,
the 625 people still employed at NWIRP McGregor were released. The closure
created an economic hardship for the surrounding communities and, as a result,
U.S. Rep. Chet Edwards sponsored special legislation to help turn the property
over to the city of McGregor for economic redevelopment. Since 1999, 3,500
of 9,600 acres have been transferred to the City of McGregor. Because of
the collaboration between the Navy, the City of McGregor, the USEPA, and
the Texas Natural Resource Conservation Commission (TNRCC), the City of McGregor
was given with the Community Economic Development Award sponsored by the
Texas Department of Economic Development.
Prior to facility shutdown, a multi-phased Resource Conservation and Recovery
Act (RCRA) Facility Investigation (RFI) was initiated in 1992 at NWIRP McGregor
targeting soil, surface water, and groundwater. The RFI responded to
environmental issues raised in the RCRA Facility Assessment completed by
the TNRCC.
In the normal course of the investigations, a suite of contaminants of concern
was identified during the RFI. However, in March 1998, the TNRCC notified
the Navy of USEPA documentation stating that NWIRP McGregor used, stored,
and disposed of ammonium perchlorate (AP), which had become an environmental
groundwater issue nationally. This revelation had the potential of slowing
down the property transfer that was already in progress.
AP is an oxidizing agent used in solid-rocket propellant. Because AP is a
salt, it dissolves rapidly in water, becomes mobile in groundwater, and persists
for many decades under typical ground and surface water conditions. Perchlorate
affects the thyroid hormone function by competitively inhibiting iodide anion
uptake reducing thyroid hormone production.
In 1997, an American Water Works Association Research Foundation panel resolved
there was no proven process for treating drinking water containing low
perchlorate concentrations. That same year, when improved chemical analytical
methods lowered perchlorates detection limit from 400 to 4 micrograms
per liter (µg/L), it was identified in many water supply systems,
particularly in western states where rocket motors were manufactured. As
a result, in March 1998, USEPA placed perchlorate on its Contaminant Candidate
List for evaluation and potential regulation under the Safe Drinking Water
Act. Various states, including Texas, established action levels for perchlorate
in drinking water, ranging from 18 to 32 µg/L.
In August 1998, after reviewing all recent perchlorate sampling results,
a comprehensive Groundwater Investigation (GWI) work plan was developed to
unify all site groundwater investigations and continue them offsite. With
increased precipitation from November 1998 to February 1999 (compared to
the dry summer), groundwater monitoring wells were installed and sampled,
and onsite and offsite surface water sampling continued. This investigation
identified migration of perchlorate from onsite source areas at concentrations
that exceeded Texas drinking water standard of 22 µg/L.
In February 1999, the TNRCC requested that interim stabilization measures
(ISMs) be implemented to abate offsite migration of perchlorate from NWIRP
McGregor. The Navy responded in March to the TNRCCs request identifying
source areas where interim corrective measures could be implemented immediately
to remove, stabilize, or control perchlorate contamination. The TNRCC approved
the response letter. In June 1999, an ISM evaluation plan was submitted to
the TNRCC and the USEPA for review. The plan recognized that contaminated
groundwater was exfiltrating to surface water at concentrations exceeding
TNRCC action levels during the wet season. The groundwater subsequently
contaminated the surface water (via natural springs and seeps) then flowed
toward Lake Belton, a primary drinking water source in central Texas. TNRCC
and USEPA quickly approved the recommendations contained in the ISM evaluation.
SOUTHDIV, along with its CLEAN II contractor, EnSafe Inc., and its design-build
contractor, CH2M Hill, was tasked to manage the contaminant investigation,
evaluate remedial alternatives, prepare a conceptual design, and oversee
final design and construction as part of NWIRP McGregors Environmental
Restoration program.
|